Nutter Butter Turkey Cupcakes


Every Thanksgiving I love to make a treat that all my kids and all my nieces and nephews will love.  Last year I made these Nutter Butter Turkey Cupcakes and they were a big hit with not only the kids, but the adults too.  My son is already asking me to make these again this year!!  They were super easy  (and fun) to make and pretty tasty too!!

Nutter Butter Turkey Cupcakes

Ingredients needed:

Box mix of cupcakes

Chocolate Frosting

Nutter Butters

Candy Corn

Candy Eyes

Orange Tic Tacs


Peanut Butter


First, bake the cupcakes as directed on the package.  Let them cool for a bit, then frost them with the chocolate  frosting.  Once they are cooled you can add the candy corn for the feathers.


While we were waiting for the cupcakes to cook and cool, my little man helped me decorate the turkey faces.  We used peanut butter to stick all the pieces onto the Nutter Butters.  We used Wilton candy eyes (found in the party section at Wal-Mart), an orange tic tac for the nose and a small piece of a twizzler for the gobble.

little helper

Last, you’ll just need to push the decorated Nutter Butter into the center of the cupcake.

turkey cupcakes

Simple, easy, and delicious Thanksgiving treat for all ages!! You can find a printable version below and I hope you’ enjoy!!

For more holiday recipes like this, follow us on Pinterest or browse our Favorite Holiday Pins Board!



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here